The meanings of violence present in the pandemic-era school
Keywords: Discourse Analysis; argumentation; violence; school writing; naming.
This thesis investigates how argumentation takes part in sustaining meanings and subject positions concerning violence in school settings in the writing of high school students in the post-pandemic context. Drawing on materialist Discourse Analysis, based on the work of Michel Pêcheux and Eni Orlandi, it takes the classroom expression “sustaining ideas” as a starting point for examining how meanings are sustained in writing. Following Orlandi, argumentation is understood as a discursive functioning aimed at sustaining meanings and subject positions. The study analyzes excerpts from ten essays selected from an archive of eighty texts written by second- and third-year high school students at a public school in Mato Grosso, Brazil, in 2026. The analysis considers the conditions under which the texts were produced and how their formulations relate to discursive memory. The excerpts show three confrontations between subject positions: naturalizing versus recognizing violent practices, treating intimate partner violence as a private matter versus calling for intervention, and attributing violence to individual behavior versus situating it within social and historical conditions. In these confrontations, violence is signified through the uptake of already available meanings, which are refused, expanded or displaced, and subject positions are constituted in the very movement of sustaining one meaning against another. The thesis’s main theoretical contribution is the notion of violence silenced through naming. It describes a discursive process in which terms such as brincadeira (“joke” or “play”) can make it harder to recognize practices that other formulations present as violent. In student writing, this process becomes visible when such terms are taken up and brought into conflict with other formulations. The thesis draws on this analysis to propose ways of teaching argumentation and approaches teachers can use when reading students’ texts.